comp 216/220?
#31
On The Tree
Join Date: Apr 2004
Location: Quiet Place in the Country, FL
Posts: 119
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Naked AV
What I meant is that whether the cam is a 206/212, or a 212/218, or a 218/222, they recommend 4* advance.
#32
TECH Veteran
iTrader: (6)
Join Date: Nov 2003
Location: Tallahassee, FL
Posts: 4,397
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Nakid.
I understand what you said, I just don't know what your point is.
If they recommend a particular camshaft to be advanced 4*, that is not the correct camshaft for the combination. You install a camshaft straight up, and they grind in however many degrees they need to give you the correct valve events.
I understand what you said, I just don't know what your point is.
If they recommend a particular camshaft to be advanced 4*, that is not the correct camshaft for the combination. You install a camshaft straight up, and they grind in however many degrees they need to give you the correct valve events.
#33
TECH Veteran
Originally Posted by SportSide 5.3
Nakid.
I understand what you said, I just don't know what your point is.
A camshaft's duration isn't effected by being advanced nor retarded.
If they recommend a particular camshaft to be advanced 4*, that is not the correct camshaft for the combination. You install a camshaft straight up, and they grind in however many degrees they need to give you the correct valve events.
I understand what you said, I just don't know what your point is.
A camshaft's duration isn't effected by being advanced nor retarded.
If they recommend a particular camshaft to be advanced 4*, that is not the correct camshaft for the combination. You install a camshaft straight up, and they grind in however many degrees they need to give you the correct valve events.
#34
TECH Veteran
iTrader: (6)
Join Date: Nov 2003
Location: Tallahassee, FL
Posts: 4,397
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From what I have learned, there is alot more than just slapping 4 degrees of timing advance to any and every camshaft. I would be interested in comparing valve events to what "your looking for", instead of automatically degreeing your camshaft 4* advanced. Do all of Comp and Cam motions camshafts have the exact same valve events? I just don't see the point in advancing any and every one of their camshafts 4*.
There has been proven cases where retarding a camshaft gained in the 1/4 mile. You want correct valve events. Thats why I'm interested in the ASP KICKERS ve's.
I wish Roger would rejoin this topic. I have a question for you, if you do decide to come back and would like to see the asp kickers valve event specs (if possible).
Roger, how much of this would you agree with? Do you grind custom camshafts, and if so, are these the steps your company follows?
Also,
What about this statement, would you agree? If so, then is your cam selection page, just best guesses?
One more.
This is a very interesting statement to me. Mainly because it says about the opposite of your initial response in this thread.
There has been proven cases where retarding a camshaft gained in the 1/4 mile. You want correct valve events. Thats why I'm interested in the ASP KICKERS ve's.
I wish Roger would rejoin this topic. I have a question for you, if you do decide to come back and would like to see the asp kickers valve event specs (if possible).
-I choose the exhaust valve opening based on the intake valve opening.
-I then pick how much overlap I want in the cam.
-From there I choose the exhaust valve closing and intake valve closing.
-These give me my VE's for a particular setup.
-From there it's just a matter of choosing the right lobes. The LSA and intake centerline are just calculations....just a byproduct of the Valve events.
-As I said before I choose the lobes based on the flow charateristics of the motor. Intake to exhaust ratio with stub pipe on the exhaust & intake on the heads, whether boost or N2O is involved, racewieght, gearing, etc, etc.
-I then pick how much overlap I want in the cam.
-From there I choose the exhaust valve closing and intake valve closing.
-These give me my VE's for a particular setup.
-From there it's just a matter of choosing the right lobes. The LSA and intake centerline are just calculations....just a byproduct of the Valve events.
-As I said before I choose the lobes based on the flow charateristics of the motor. Intake to exhaust ratio with stub pipe on the exhaust & intake on the heads, whether boost or N2O is involved, racewieght, gearing, etc, etc.
Also,
Every motor is different. What works well in one application may be totally wrong in another. Too many variables to post all the little things like this that go into designing the correct profile.
One more.
All motors I've slapped reverse-splits in have generally responded the same. Idle is much more stable, average power across the RPM band is increased....
#35
TECH Addict
Join Date: Jul 2002
Location: fayetteville AR
Posts: 2,708
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I should say I dont like the way it works with my setup. Even with my 2500 stall it still suffered low end tq. I also think this cam peaks too early. I will be selling mine CHEAP very soon
#36
10 Second Club
iTrader: (3)
Join Date: Mar 2004
Location: orlando, fl
Posts: 4,257
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by SportSide 5.3
One more.
This is a very interesting statement to me. Mainly because it says about the opposite of your initial response in this thread.
All motors I've slapped reverse-splits in have generally responded the same. Idle is much more stable, average power across the RPM band is increased....
#37
10 Second Club
iTrader: (3)
Join Date: Mar 2004
Location: orlando, fl
Posts: 4,257
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by SportSide 5.3
Roger,
I still haven't grasped your logic on adding more exhaust duration to provide a fatter power band.
I still haven't grasped your logic on adding more exhaust duration to provide a fatter power band.
Originally Posted by SportSide 5.3
Few questions:
-How does more exhuast duration make tuning easier? I've always heard the other way around, where more exhaust duration causes more misfire codes.
-How does more exhuast duration make tuning easier? I've always heard the other way around, where more exhaust duration causes more misfire codes.
Originally Posted by SportSide 5.3
-Again, if we are intake limited, why add more exhaust duration?
Originally Posted by SportSide 5.3
-Shouldn't the valve events match the head flow and the users requirments?
Originally Posted by SportSide 5.3
I'm just lost on most of your cam specs, where almost all favor 4* or more of exhaust duration. Hopefully, you don't take my questions the wrong way. I've heard of good results and am trying to figure it out.
Originally Posted by SportSide 5.3
BTW:
Would it be possible for you to list the valve events of say the asp kicker?
Thanks.
Would it be possible for you to list the valve events of say the asp kicker?
Thanks.
hope this helps you some. hopefully VHP phone lines will be back up soon and he can add to what i tried to relay from our conversation about this.
#38
In terms of adding advance (or retard) to a cam, think of it as a tuning tool. Changing cam timing to suit track (or street) conditions can be a very valuable tool that can produce a desired result. Usually, this result is verified by driver input and the stopwatch when on the track, rather than stricktly on a dyno. Of course this is all precluded by the appropriate cam selection to start with. FWIW.
Andy
Andy