What Transmission to Buy?
#21
Pretty sure the OEM Goodwrench 700R my dad bought a couple years ago came with a lifetime when installed by a dealer... Regardless, this would be an example of a better option for him IMO. Comes with a shift kit installed, and a vette servo is a $25/half hour project. Pretty decent price for the 3yr/100k warranty and should serve his purpose fine. If it blows in 3.5 years, he can get another and still be on top pricewise, when compared to some of the other suggestions lol.
http://cgi.ebay.com/ebaymotors/CHEVY...Q5fAccessories
http://cgi.ebay.com/ebaymotors/CHEVY...Q5fAccessories
#24
#25
Joined: Apr 2004
Posts: 16,820
Likes: 2
From: In a van DOWN BY THE RIVER
Yes it is my DD, I don't abuse the hell out of it alot but when I do I beat on it.. Has about 10 1/4 mile passes on it, more then I can count WOT blasts... Don't be fooled, Pbuilt builds a bad *** trans.. I have no complaints
#26
Cheap transmission are exactly that....cheap transmissions. This is one area that you don't want to skimp on. Agreed, that a mostly stock truck can be fine with a mostly stock trans (even though mine didn't...my 60E couldn't take my mild cam and no torque management), but I doubt that a GM trans, installed by the dealer so that it has some sort of extensive warranty, is going to cost less than a decent middle of the road FLT or Performabuilt. You could always go to those chain stores, but be prepared to go back again, and again, and again, until they finally get it right, if they ever do. Those places should just velcro the transmissions in after they rebuild them for easy removal the next time...
#27
Cheap transmission are exactly that....cheap transmissions. This is one area that you don't want to skimp on. Agreed, that a mostly stock truck can be fine with a mostly stock trans (even though mine didn't...my 60E couldn't take my mild cam and no torque management), but I doubt that a GM trans, installed by the dealer so that it has some sort of extensive warranty, is going to cost less than a decent middle of the road FLT or Performabuilt. You could always go to those chain stores, but be prepared to go back again, and again, and again, until they finally get it right, if they ever do. Those places should just velcro the transmissions in after they rebuild them for easy removal the next time...
#28
#29
FLT and Performabuilt both have excellent reputations around here, I'm currently paying off an FLT Level7 65E myself. There are certain things that you get what you pay for and don't want to skimp on...performance units such as engines and transmissions fall into this category. It's been almost a year since I last drove my truck since the trans blew...I could have gotten a junk yard unit or a cheaper built unit and been on the road by now, but I don't want to have to pull my trans on a monthly basis. Do yourself a favor and go with the pros who have built their reputations through years of performance...pay a little more now or a lot later 

Cheap transmission are exactly that...cheap transmissions. This is one area that you don't want to skimp on. Agreed, that a mostly stock truck can be fine with a mostly stock trans (even though mine didn't...my 60E couldn't take my mild cam and no torque management), but I doubt that a GM trans, installed by the dealer so that it has some sort of extensive warranty, is going to cost less than a decent middle of the road FLT or Performabuilt. You could always go to those chain stores, but be prepared to go back again, and again, and again, until they finally get it right, if they ever do. Those places should just velcro the transmissions in after they rebuild them for easy removal the next time...
Last edited by fastnblu; Feb 21, 2010 at 10:30 PM.
#30
I guess I just see things differently than some of you... It's obvious that the site sponsors build quality performance transmissions, but if you are willing to sit here and say that any one of these units can't have a mechanical failure that is completely out of the hands of the builder then you are a fool. Yes, those more expensive performance tranny's are comprised of higher quality parts in most area's, but does he really need that??? He has a 230rwhp truck. Let me ask you this... If he buys a performance tranny and it fail's in 1 1/2 years for some random reason, once the warranty has expired (which happens on a daily basis when it comes to transmissions), do you think the company who built it will feel guilty enough about their "built" tranny failing under an EXTREMELY mild motor to build him another transmission for free???? Don't think so... A built tranny should run forever in a mild truck like his, but things break; it's the nature of the beast. That warranty would have come in pretty handy then, huh??? 
If I had a mild HP engine like he has in his setup, I would buy a transmission with the longest warranty possible because after all that piece of paper with the warranty details on it and the receipt stapled to it is the only thing that means **** when it fails.
So, if you want to spend the unnecessary money for a "built" tranny that you don't need (keep in mind the performance aspect will be the same in either, with the less expensive tranny coming with a shift kit installed and you adding the $25 servo which is what you would get in a mid grade performance tranny), and receive a warranty that is 1/3 the length, then that is your choice. I personally am not willing to invest that kind of confidence in any transmission when given the option of a better warranty, because I realize that things break in transmissions that are out of anyone's control. Some run for 70k, others run for 170k. I would rather spend my money elsewhere, and receive pretty much the same performance in the mean time.
However, realize that my recommendations would be completely different if we were talking about a truck with a blown 6.0. Warranty's fly out the door on transmissions built for that kind of hp... Performabuilt would be at the top of the list then with their 1yr tranny, 2yr tranny/converter combo warranties.

If I had a mild HP engine like he has in his setup, I would buy a transmission with the longest warranty possible because after all that piece of paper with the warranty details on it and the receipt stapled to it is the only thing that means **** when it fails.
So, if you want to spend the unnecessary money for a "built" tranny that you don't need (keep in mind the performance aspect will be the same in either, with the less expensive tranny coming with a shift kit installed and you adding the $25 servo which is what you would get in a mid grade performance tranny), and receive a warranty that is 1/3 the length, then that is your choice. I personally am not willing to invest that kind of confidence in any transmission when given the option of a better warranty, because I realize that things break in transmissions that are out of anyone's control. Some run for 70k, others run for 170k. I would rather spend my money elsewhere, and receive pretty much the same performance in the mean time.
However, realize that my recommendations would be completely different if we were talking about a truck with a blown 6.0. Warranty's fly out the door on transmissions built for that kind of hp... Performabuilt would be at the top of the list then with their 1yr tranny, 2yr tranny/converter combo warranties.




